• Give me access to SECRET EPISODES
  • Episodes
  • Watch
  • Listen
  • Subscribe
Menu
  • Episodes
  • Watch
  • Listen
  • Subscribe
  • Give me access to SECRET EPISODES
PrevPrevious EpisodeDr. Newell Bringhurst on Saints, Slaves, and Blacks
Next ExpisodeA Personal NoteNext

How Lester Bush Debunked the Missouri Thesis

We’re continuing our conversation with Dr. Newell Bringhurst.  We will continue where we left off and explain in more detail the Missouri Thesis.

Newell:  The Missouri Thesis is the argument that the origins of black priesthood denial go back to the Mormon problems in Missouri.  Missouri is a slave state and the Latter-day Saints go into Jackson County in the early 1830s, 1831-1832.  Most of them are from the north, they are northerners.  They are basically Yankees, people from the northern states so immediately there is a system of tension of tension between the Mormons/Latter-day Saints with the people that are there, have come there from the south and settled Missouri.  A lot of people have brought their slaves and so on.  There aren’t a huge number of slaves in Missouri.  During the Civil War it was a border state, but there was enough slavery that it was a legal institution in Missouri.

The argument of the Missouri Thesis is the Mormons coming in tended to be anti-slavery because they were coming from the northern part of the country.  Those that were there that had migrated from the south were pro-slavery.  So the Mormons could see that this was a difficult situation.  To try to strengthen their position in Missouri, they saw Independence, [Missouri] as a center place for Zion.  That was where they were going to gather in the last days in the early revelations [in the Doctrine & Covenants.]  They saw Zion and Independence where that was going to be the final gathering place before the coming of the Millennium and the end times.  It was very important for the Mormons from that point of view.

So the argument is that Joseph Smith felt it necessary to accommodate the pro-slavery position and the anti-black position.  In order to accommodate that they were willing to—especially as it became more difficult during the course of the 1830s, they decided that they would deny blacks the priesthood.

Lester Bush’s groundbreaking article discounted the Missouri Thesis and connected the priesthood and temple ban to Brigham Young rather than Joseph Smith.

Then Lester Bush comes along.  He’s doing a lot more intense research than Taggart did.  Taggart’s research is not thorough. In the meantime Lester Bush has been working assiduously on his study of blacks in the church, and he has been asked to write a review of Taggart’s.  It turns out that it is a review essay published in Dialogue in 1970.  His review essay is longer and more thorough than Taggart’s original book.  That’s the upstart.  I’m sure you’re familiar with it.  You’ve probably read both side by side.  There’s no comparison with regards to the thoroughness and the rigor of the sources utilized and the way that it was written.

Then of course Bush comes along three years, four years later with his definitive Dialogue article, Mormonism’s Negro Policy[1] that is the classic—the first real legitimately scholarly examination of the issue, the path-breaking article that we all, those of us that came after him, owe him a lot for:  myself, Armand Mauss, and all those who came after me.

Bush’s article was cited by President Kimball as being highly influential as Kimball studied the roots of the ban.  We also discuss some prominent slaveholding LDS Church leaders.  Check out our conversation…..

—

YouTube player

[paypal-donation]

[1] The article is titled Mormonism’s Negro Doctrine:  An Historical Overview, and found at https://www.dialoguejournal.com/2012/mormonisms-negro-doctrine-an-historical-overview/

Bush's Dialogue article refuting Missouri Thesis

https://media.blubrry.com/gospeltangents/p/https://content.blubrry.com/gospeltangents/128-Missouri-Bush.mp3

Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 16:48 — 15.5MB) | Embed

Subscribe: Google Podcasts | Email | RSS | More

No related products found.

More Podcasts with these Guests

  • *Remembering Armand Mauss (Part 7 of 7)
  • Race, Priesthood, & Randy Bott (Part 6 of 7)
  • Racism in Mormon Scripture (Part 5 of 7)
  • Pros & Cons of Race Essay (Part 4 of 7)
  • Critiquing Polygamy Essays & Sources (Part 3 of 7)

Get more information on the people and things discussed in this episode:

  • Guest: Newell Bringhurst
  • Theology: Theology
  • Black Mormon History, LDS Leaders, Racial Priesthood/Temple Ban
  • Historical Mentions Brigham Young, Mormon History, Stephen Taggart
  • Tags: best Mormon history podcast, Brigham Young, Gospel Tangents, GT Podcast, iTunes, LDS priesthood ban, Lester Bush, Missouri Thesis, Priesthood ban, Racial Stereotypes, Stephen Taggart

Tell me when the next episode drops!

PrevPrevious EpisodeDr. Newell Bringhurst on Saints, Slaves, and Blacks
Next ExpisodeA Personal NoteNext

One Response

  1. Avatar of Erica Erica says:
    March 1, 2020 at 12:32 pm

    This proves NOTHING and certainly doesn’t debunk anything. He himself when quoting Brigham Young starts the quote with the word “If”. If Joseph Smith never officially made the statement he’s making it now. These were mortal men who we have abundant evidence were not perfect; actual scripture related to their mistakes. Given what was going on at the time regarding slavery it is not a far leap that this policy was indeed another human error. I am thankful for these men, their contributions and their sacrifices but I do not worship them and I definitely do not think every word or action was infallible.
    And I would also like to point out that the way your guest refers to them as “the blacks” also stirs distaste. His heir is one of superiority.

Comments are closed.

  • Date: February 18, 2018
  • Guest: Newell Bringhurst
  • Theology: Theology
  • Black Mormon History, LDS Leaders, Racial Priesthood/Temple Ban
  • Historical Mentions Brigham Young, Mormon History, Stephen Taggart
  • Tags: best Mormon history podcast, Brigham Young, Gospel Tangents, GT Podcast, iTunes, LDS priesthood ban, Lester Bush, Missouri Thesis, Priesthood ban, Racial Stereotypes, Stephen Taggart
  • Posted By: RickB

Rick Bennett, Host

Rick Bennett is the friendly host of Gospel Tangents LDS Podcast: The Best Source for Mormon History, Science, and Theology. Book Rick for your fireside or conference.

More Interviews

  • Ben Spackman
  • David Ostler
  • Denver Snuffer
  • Lachlan McKay
  • Lindsay Hansen Park
  • Margaret Toscano
  • Richard Bushman
  • Sally Gordon
  • Terryl Givens
  • Ugo Perego...
View all 100+ Interviewees

Proud to be an Amazon Associate

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Subscribe

Subscribe to Gospel Tangents LDS Podcast and go ad-free!

Go Ad-Free

$ 5 Month
  • View all Podcasts with NO ADS
Don't Show Me Ads!

Show Me Videos First!

$ 8 Month
  • No Ads
  • Full-length Videos
  • GT Insiders Community Access
Make Me an Insider!

Email Me Transcripts

$ 10 Month
  • No Ads
  • Full-length Videos
  • GT Insiders Community Access
  • Receive PDF Transcripts of every episode by email
Send Me Transcripts!
best value

Grow My Collection

$ 20 Month
  • No Ads
  • Full-length Videos
  • GT Insiders Community Access
  • Receive PDF Transcripts of every episode by email
  • Collect every Gospel Tangents episode with a printed transcript delivered by mail
Build My Collection!

Give Me
One-On-One Access

$ 100 Month
  • No Ads
  • Full-length Videos
  • GT Insiders Community Access
  • Receive PDF Transcripts of every episode by email
  • Collect every Gospel Tangents episode with a printed transcript delivered by mail
  • Meet with Rick personally, one-on-one, for an hour each month!
Sign Me Up!
Have educated, non-judgmental discussions with the most personable LDS podcaster in the business.

Subscribe

Go ad-free, get written transcripts, and talk to Rick one-on-one!
Stop Seeing Ads

Rick Bennett, Host of Gospel Tangents

Rick Bennett is the friendly, independent historian at the heart of Gospel Tangents LDS Podcast: The Best Source for Mormon History, Science, and Theology. When he isn't interviewing Mormon scholars, prophets, and others, he is teaching math and statistics at Utah Valley University. He also freelances as a research biostatistician in the fields of Dermatology and Traumatic Brian Injuries, as well as in the network television/cable T.V. industries as a sports statistician. Rick holds a Master of Statistics Degree from the University of Utah.

Contact Rick
Book Rick for your Event
0 +
Podcast Episodes
0
People Interviewed
  • Home
  • About
  • Episodes
  • Subscribe
  • Fan Shop
  • Book Rick
  • Contact Us
Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Episodes
  • Subscribe
  • Fan Shop
  • Book Rick
  • Contact Us
Copyright 2022, Gospel Tangents. All Rights Reserved.