In the final installment Nancy Ross and Jessica Finnigan discuss their Mormon garment research, co-authors of Mormon Garments, Sacred and Secret explore the sociological themes of their book, the shifting historical meanings behind garments, and how their taboo-breaking research has been received by the community.
Sacred vs. Secret: A Matter of Belief
The authors break down the sociological framework of their book, organizing their findings around paired themes like “secrecy and sacredness,” “shame and worthiness,” and “obedience and control.” They argue that practically, the concepts of “secret” and “sacred” operate in the exact same way regarding garments, but the terminology wearers use heavily depends on their level of belief. Conforming believers tend to embrace the uplifting language of “sacredness,” while those experiencing doubt are more likely to view the practice through the lens of “secrecy” and institutional control.
Don’t miss our other conversations Nancy Ross: https://gospeltangents.com/people/nancy-ross/
Copyright © 2026
Gospel Tangents
All Rights Reserved
The Evolution of Modesty and Institutional Control
While Joseph Smith’s original garments were not about modesty, the cultural meaning of garments shifted significantly in the 1950s to become a primary tool for enforcing modesty boundaries, especially for women. The authors discuss how recent modernizations—such as the introduction of sleeveless garments—have caused emotional dissonance for older members who made significant personal sacrifices to adhere to previous, stricter modesty standards. The authors note that even when the church relaxes its rules by an inch or two, it ultimately serves as a reaffirmation of the institution’s power to control what its members wear.
Wrestling Meaning from Fundamentalists
The episode also highlights a fascinating historical power struggle in the 1920s. As fundamentalist Mormons clung to the original 19th-century garment design—claiming the LDS church’s 1923 modernizations were completely invalid—the mainstream church had to figure out a way to wrestle the meaning of the practice back. To do this, the LDS church actually expanded the language of the temple endowment to explicitly emphasize that the garment’s true meaning came from its marks, rather than an unalterable pattern.
Opening Overdue Conversations
Despite some immediate, dismissive pushback from critics who assumed the book would be a hostile exposé, the authors report that the overall reception has been overwhelmingly positive. Ross and Finnegan strived to write with a neutral tone and deep compassion for their former believing selves. By lifting the heavy taboo surrounding the topic, the book is providing members with the vocabulary to finally reflect on their personal experiences. Most importantly, it is giving spouses and friends the permission to have open, overdue conversations about the complex intersection of bodies, sexuality, and the physical realities of wearing garments.
0:00 Garments/Temple are Secret! (and sacred)
6:34 Are new garments immodest?
12:34 Book’s reception
Don’t miss our other conversations Nancy Ross: https://gospeltangents.com/people/nancy-ross/
Copyright © 2026
Gospel Tangents
All Rights Reserved
Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 0:31 — 577.5KB) | Embed
Subscribe: Email | | More
