Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 20:57 — 19.4MB) | Embed
Subscribe: Android | Email | Google Podcasts | RSS | More
If you were born after 1975, you may not have heard of the John Birch Society. Dr. Matt Harris tells us more about this group, and President Benson’s allegiance to this anti-communist group. Check out our conversation….
Matt: He meets a man named Robert Welch who founds this very controversial anticommunist organization called the John Birch Society, named after a fallen GI in World War II, John Birch. Welch organizes the Birch Society in 1958. He writes an extremely controversial book that will get him pilloried in the national press. It’s called The Politician. He writes it in ’58, but it’s not published until ’63.
So it’s this big long manuscript that he shares privately with some friends and Benson will get a copy of this manuscript before it’s published in book form. In the manuscript, it says that Eisenhower and members of his cabinet are communists. He also said that Milton Eisenhower, the president’s brother and close advisor, is also commie. He spells out several people. He says that the CIA director, John Foster Dulles, the Secretary of State–they’re all commies. He gives several reasons why. Eisenhower doesn’t curtail the New Deal policies. This is liberal new deal. Of course, a lot of conservatives at the time thought that liberalism equated to socialism and communism. Well, one of the things that President Eisenhower doesn’t do is drastically roll back the New Deal and that leaves him open for criticism among people like Robert Welch. There’s some other things. Welch criticizes some decisions that President Eisenhower had made, General Eisenhower had made during World War II and somehow that equates to communism. I mean, really, it’s far reaching here.
I guess what surprises me is how Benson turns on Eisenhower, after the two had been such good friends!
Henry D. Moyle is in the First Presidency when this letter is sent out. He’s a Democrat and Hugh B. Brown’s a Democrat, too, the other counselor at the time. You can imagine they’re just mortified over this. Here’s a moderate Republican now getting accused of being a commie–a five-star general who spent his entire adult life fighting communism and now his erstwhile cabinet secretary accuses him of being a commie.
Moyle calls him in. He calls him Taft. Moyle called Taft in and one participant, or one witness said, “He ripped Taft, ripped him.” One of the things he said was, “How could you be disloyal to President Eisenhower like this?” You can imagine that as he’s sending this around, his son, in the meantime joins the Birch Society and becomes a high ranking official in the Birch Society. He’s the National Communications Director, I think, is one of his titles. And he’s going around giving speeches to Birch audiences, both in Utah, Idaho, actually one here in Denver, Colorado. He calls President Eisenhower a commie, out in the open–the news media is there.
GT: Reed Benson?
Matt: Reed Benson, yeah. Ezra is a little more circumspect. President–Elder Benson at that point knew that it probably wasn’t good karma to give speeches, you know, so his son would do that. But Elder Benson did get himself into trouble in 1963.
Check out our conversation, as well as our first conversation about how Benson joined the Eisenhower cabinet.
Just a couple of minor quibbles.
To begin, I inherited my antipathy for the John Birch Society from my father back in the mid-60s, beginning when I was about ten years old. And nothing I’ve seen since then makes me think any more highly of them and their nonsense.
First, John Birch was actually shot by members of the Red Army 10 days after the Japanese surrendered. So, technically, not a casualty of the war or of our foes in that war.
Second, it’s ahistorical to say that Eisenhower spent his adult life fighting communism. In World War 1, the enemy we fought were the Central Powers, Germany and Austria-Hungary. No fighting of communism for Eisenhower there.
During the interwar period, Eisenhower was posted either in the US, mostly in staff officer positions or at the War College, or in the Philippines, on General MacArthur’s staff. Again, no fighting of communism there.
During World War II, the USSR was our ally, and it was German Nazism and Italian Fascism and Japanese imperialism that the US was fighting. In Europe the USSR had the same basic war aim as the Western Allies–to defeat the German war-making capability. We can infer that Ike didn’t like Communism from his later statements, but his job was to destroy the Nazi capacity to make war, and he adhered to the boundaries established in the Yalta Conference even though others might have wanted to push farther into Germany.
Finally, when Eisenhower was president, he was brought face to face with the threats posed by the USSR. And he spent the eight years of his presidency trying to diminish those threats by maintaining a strong deterrent and through diplomacy, while at the same time keeping the US out of war. He had seen enough of war in his lifetime, and had no desire to see any more.
So you could say that he spent those years of his life fighting communism.